Is Homeschooling Really That Controversial?
Each fall when school begins, a growing
number of school-aged children do not head off to a classroom.
Instead, they learn at home with their families or with other
children in their communities. Homeschooling takes many forms,
from a daily routine following a scheduled curriculum to
child-led learning in which parents supervise and help. Choosing
to homeschool or to traditionally educate a child is often a
difficult and confusing decision for parents and guardians. To
help them make the best choice possible, this brochure answers
basic questions about homeschooling and suggests other useful
sources of information.
Do Families Have a Right to School Their Children at Home?
All states allow homeschooling. Typically, a
state's statutes, through a court ruling, an attorney general
opinion, or a regulation that interprets a school attendance law
to include homeschooling, consider homeschooling a legitimate
option for meeting compulsory education requirements. Because
each state regulates homeschooling differently, parents should
examine local laws and consult with other homeschoolers before
proceeding.
In every state, parents must, at a minimum,
notify a state or local education agency of their intent to
educate their children at home and identify the children
involved. Several states require the submission of proposed
curricula and tests or have educational requirements for
parents. A few even test parents. Only Michigan requires
certified teachers to be involved in homeschooling programs, but
the state allows parents to choose a program's teacher and does
not specify a minimum level of teacher supervision. (Michigan
courts have excused parents from the certification requirement
if they have religious objections.)
The U.S. Supreme Court has not ruled
explicitly on homeschooling, but it did rule against compulsory
school requirements in Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972). The Supreme
Court has also upheld the right, subject to reasonable state
requirements, of parents to direct the education of their
children.
What Does the Federal Government Do for Homeschoolers?
Government regulation and support of home
schooling is carried out primarily at the state level. However,
the federal government also plays an important role by
disseminating research-based information on homeschooling to
policy makers and others and by supporting research on a broad
range of issues affecting teaching and learning.
Most federal support for education is
dedicated to programs for children who have special needs, such
as low-achieving children, children with limited English
proficiency, and children with disabilities. Generally, local
districts have the option of offering services under these
programs to homeschoolers who meet the districts' criteria for
eligibility.
How Do Educators and Policy Makers View
Homeschooling?
Homeschooling is controversial. The National
Parent Teacher Association opposes the practice, as do the
National Education Association and the National Association of
Elementary School Principals. Other groups such as the American
Civil Liberties Union maintain that parents have a
constitutional right to school their children at home. Though
they don't necessarily approve of homeschooling, a majority of
Americans responding to the 1988 Phi Delta Kappa Gallup poll
believed that parents have a right to try it. State legislatures
agree, and over the past 20 years they have responded favorably
to homeschoolers seeking more flexible compulsory education
laws.
How Well Do Homeschooled Children Do?
Homeschooling's academic worth is hotly
contested. It is difficult to obtain a representative sample of
homeschooled children, and researchers cannot say for certain
whether these children would do better or worse in a public or
private school. Scores of homeschoolers who have taken
state-mandated tests or who have provided their results to
researchers indicate that while some homeschoolers test below
average, a larger number test above that mark.
Proponents and opponents also disagree on how
well-adjusted homeschooled children are. Although it appears to
be true that children who are homeschooled spend less time with
same-age children and more time with adults and children of
different ages, research has not found that homeschooling harms
children's social or psychological development. On the contrary,
these children often demonstrate better social adjustment
than their traditionally schooled peers.
Opponents argue that homeschooling is harmful
to children because it isolates them from other children in
their community. However, homeschooling is rarely conducted in
total isolation. Many families participate in homeschool support
groups, scouting, church and recreational activities, and other
associations.
Through these activities, homeschooled
children share experiences with people outside their immediate
families. Although some homeschoolers and their associations
emphasize affiliations only with people who share their
religious beliefs, many actively seek religious, cultural, and
racial diversity. In fact, one national magazine, The Drinking
Gourd, is devoted to multicultural homeschooling.
What About College Admissions?
Homeschooling teenagers should contact the
colleges and universities they would like to attend and ask
about their admission policies. In a 1994 telephone poll
conducted by the author of this brochure, a select group of
admissions officers from large universities and colleges
indicated willingness to consider applications from homeschooled
students. In addition, all of the officers said that they
accept standardized admission test scores-along with other
material showing experience in learning and collaborating with
others-in the absence of a regular high school transcript.
Although admissions officers do not monitor this practice, some
estimated that they admit a handful of undergraduates each year
without a transcript. Interested teenagers should ask their
local homeschool association for the names of college students
who were homeschooled and would not mind offering advice about
the college application process.
What Resources Are Available to Homeschoolers?
To get started, most homeschooling families
join local support groups. Families often find these groups by
word of mouth or through public or private schools, religious
groups, or state or national associations. At least one
homeschooling association is active in every state. These groups
offer advice and information and hold conferences at which
families who school at home discuss legal, philosophical, and
teaching issues.
Parents can also find guidance in books,
magazines, and newsletters. Homeschooling Resources for Parents
and Students, lists materials and Internet resources that cover
a wide range of homeschooling issues. Checkout this site!
http://rsts.net/home
Some school districts have established
centers at which families may enroll in classes or obtain
resources and instructional support. Such arrangements are
called shared schooling, dual enrollment, or assisted
homeschooling. Some districts also allow homeschoolers to attend
public school part-time. Many private schools, some public
schools, and the state of Alaska provide homeschoolers with
texts, materials, and support. Homeschoolers also rely on
libraries, museums, parks department programs, churches, civic
associations, and other local institutions.